[Backend] Validate beats in code before any prose is written #333
Closed
opened 2026-08-25 20:38:52 +00:00 by claude-bot
·
1 comment
No Branch/Tag specified
main
feat/1328-fill-it-in
feat/1328-fill-frontend
feat/1328-fill-backend
feat/9-foundry-push
fix/9-foundry-live
feat/9-foundry-push-frontend
renovate/celery-5.x
feat/5-foundry-connect
feat/9-foundry-push-backend
feat/9-foundry-push-module
feat/5-foundry-frontend
feat/5-foundry-backend
feat/5-foundry-module
release/v4.8.0-rc1
docs/d341-convert-draft
feat/958-update-to-version
feat/958-convert-sheet
feat/958-pathbuilder-import-frontend
fix/1360-heading-order
feat/958-pathbuilder-import-backend
feat/11-weekly-digest
feat/1341-auto-update
docs/d332-superseded
chore/1345-names-cleanup
feat/1342-mentioned-pages
feat/1328-recipes
fix/1346-pgdg-key
perf/1247-shared-recording-stream
chore/132-gitleaks-allowlist
release/v4.7.1
spike/foundry-module
release/v4.7.1-rc1
docs/decisions-d332-d337
fix/bot-certifi
chore/release-4.7.0
chore/release-4.7.0-rc4
chore/deps-4.7.0
chore/release-4.7.0-rc3
fix/1280-quote-must-say-it
fix/1257-names-row-squeeze
chore/release-4.7.0-rc2
fix/1245-pg-upgrade-count
chore/release-4.7.0-rc1
feat/1257-names-in-prep
feat/1257-be
feat/1257-fe
feat/1257-rating-fixes
design/1328-fill-it-in
feat/1257-name-splits
fix/1326-redis-503
feat/1280-fact-suggestions
feat/1280-be
feat/1280-fe
design/1280-fact-suggestions
feat/1279-infobox
feat/1279-be
feat/1279-fe
feat/1321-shelf-copies
design/1279-infobox
feat/1243-table-find
feat/1257-who-rated
feat/1243-prep-drawer
feat/1243-sheet-pickers
design/1243-browse-in-place
feat/1315-hotwords-default
feat/1242-system-filters
feat/1257-more-name-styles
feat/506-leg3-hotwords
design/1242-system-filters
fix/1302-packs-polish
feat/1241-rules-library
design/1241-rules-library
feat/1245-postgres-18
integ/4.6.2
fix/1263-map-ui-2
fix/1263-map-server
fix/1263-map-ui-1
fix/1261-editor-link-menu
fix/1229-axe-4.14-name-mismatch
renovate/axllent-mailpit-1.x
renovate/eslint-monorepo
renovate/authlib-1.x
chore/release-4.6.0
chore/release-4.6.0-rc2
fix/460-rc2-screens
fix/460-rc2-server
fix/release-prerelease-exit
chore/release-4.6.0-rc1
feat/125-campaign-templates
feat/126-calendar
feat/1181-pictures-and-files
feat/1190-event-people
integ/4.6.0
feat/1191-line-of-the-night
feat/1200-starter-packs
chore/bot-multidict-and-playwright-group
fix/1202-this-week-answered-count
fix/122-124-leftovers
fix/1178-get-routes-that-write
fix/1203-journeys-check-names
design/125-campaign-templates
feat/126-calendar-engine
design/126-in-world-calendar
fix/1189-cited-stamp-in-range
fix/1189-v4-looser-check
fix/1189-richer-beats
fix/1113-export-bind-lists
fix/1154-release-notes-by-file
chore/release-4.5.0
chore/release-4.5.0-rc12
fix/1135-wiki-markup-as-text
fix/demo-usage-cost-in-window
chore/release-4.5.0-rc11
fix/1121-sheet-consistency
fix/1121-sheet-5e-terms-and-card-hp
copy/1122-busiest-pages
fix/1121-relevant-choices
fix/1121-wiki-create-npc-save-sheet-links
fix/1029-menu-stays-on-screen
docs/prototype-transcript-bin-wording
fix/1023-editor-save-row-back-scroll
fix/1020-search-exact-first
fix/1020-table-prep
fix/1020-shell-wordmark-footer-bell
fix/1020-wiki-article-party
fix/872-admin-kept-until-phone-tables
feat/l13-milestone-level-waiting
fix/1000-1001-bell-older-setup-context
fix/999-pronouns-in-prompts
fix/l19-other-class-feats
fix/1010-transcript-window-ordinary-confirm
docs/d254-d269-decisions
fix/702-member-search
fix/680-transcript-bin
fix/993-unidentified-prompts
fix/841-redis-timeouts
fix/990-binned-not-exported
fix/830-export-prep-shelf
fix/deps-audit-2026-10-01
fix/877-title-reads
fix/798-audio-received-at
build/lane11-17-j7
build/lane11-16-levelup
build/lane11-14-seams
build/lane11-14-seed
build/lane11-15-start
build/lane11-13-old-block-out
fix/980-review-r3
build/lane11-12-block
build/lane11-8-packs
fix/demo-seed-canonical-names
build/lane11-11-hot-half
docs/l11-decisions
build/lane11-7-convert
build/lane11-10-editing
fix/npm-audit-brace-expansion
build/lane11-9-sheet-page
fix/bot-pyjwt
build/lane11-6-content
fix/lane11-rank-names
build/lane11-2b-language
build/lane11-4-js-evaluator
build/lane11-3-server
build/lane11-5a-pf2e
build/lane11-5b-5e
feat/design-admin
build/lane11-2-evaluator
build/lane11-1-sheet-pieces
build/lane11-0-drawing
fix/943-quest-objectives-fk
fix/prepsheet-shelf-flake
fix/945-leftovers
build/demo-gm-copy
fix/901-email-landings
build/lane10-8-journeys
build/demo-seed-lanes-8-10
fix/887-gm-own-confirmation
build/lane9-5-j1-admin
fix/918-audience-click
fix/useasync-overtaken
ci/939-critical-path
test/937-backend-suite-speed
chore/claude-orchestration
fix/924-xp-gm-only
fix/session-stale-poll
docs/decisions-d239-d242
fix/930-pypdf
build/lane8-journeys
build/925-quest-editor
fix/894-private-page-pictures
build/lane8-p4-drafts
build/lane8-p7-map
build/lane8-p6-handouts-rules
fix/wiki-fixture-names
build/lane10-d227-test-usage
fix/rsvp-horizon-test-tuesday
fix/media-volume-owner
build/lane8-p3-editor
fix/912-unidentified-rename
build/lane8-p5-party-quests
build/lane8-handout-takeback
build/lane10-pickers
build/lane8-p2-article
build/lane8-6-map
build/lane10-7b-email-pages
build/lane8-5-handouts
build/lane10-7a-test-the-bot-pages
build/lane8-p1-pages
build/lane8-4-quests
build/lane8-2b-feeds
build/lane8-3-parties
build/lane8-2a-links
build/lane10-5-commands
build/lane9-6-seed
build/lane10-4b-reactions
build/lane9-4d-pages
build/lane9-4c-pages
build/lane10-4a-posts
build/lane10-3-email
fix/891-web-fonts
build/lane9-4b-pages
build/lane10-6-test-the-bot
build/lane10-2-notify-out
build/lane8-1-wiki-text
build/lane9-4a-frame
design/lane10-drawings
fix/j6-budget
fix/j5-phone-flake
fix/869-test-leaks
fix/843-record-start-followups
build/lane7-all
build/lane6-all
build/lane9-b2-server
chore/changelog-fragments
docs/decisions-d218
build/lane9-a-owner-overview
fix/rule-card-level-label
fix/834-retention-semantics
fix/o3c-record-without-announcement
docs/decisions-d179
docs/decisions-d131-d170
fix/851-commit-before-response
build/lane6-j3-seed
build/lane9-b1-d67-identity
fix/841-blocking-loop
build/lane9-c-backups-audit
fix/vote-race-and-start-commit
fix/recording-announcement
fix/proposal-read-leak
fix/last-admin-guard
build/lane6-p4c-planning
build/lane6-p4b-margin
build/lane6-p4a-sheet
build/lane5-j4-seed
build/lane6-base
build/lane7-pages-talk
build/lane5-pages
build/lane7-pages-safety
build/lane7-p3-safety
build/lane7-p2-notify
build/lane6-p3-planning
build/lane6-p2-history
build/lane6-p1b-items
build/lane7-p1-threads
build/lane5-p6-faces
build/lane6-p1a-sheet
build/lane5-p5-find
build/lane5-p4a-board
build/lane5-p4b-scenes
build/lane5-p3-live
build/lane5-base
build/lane5-p2-cards
docs/lane5-decisions
build/review-r2-wide
fix/review-r1
build/lane5-p1-scenes
build/demo-seed
build/lane4-journeys-j5
build/lane4-page-review-b
build/lane4-page-review-a
build/lane4-page-read
build/lane4-journeys
build/lane4-page-sess2
build/lane4-page-sess1
build/lane4-notes
build/lane4-discord-on-approval
build/lane4-scheduling
build/lane4-versions
build/760-session-number
build/lane4-decisions
build/797-erase-no-regenerate
build/test-race-audit
build/lane3-completions
build/794-dark-only
build/796-titles-scroll
build/791-retention-anchor
build/a11y-sweep
build/shell-followups
build/retention-preview
build/753-backup-readback
docs/d91-d93
build/lane3-j1
build/ci-harness-paths-selftest
fix/useauth-test-race
build/ci-harness-paths
build/777-ai-settings-read
build/lane3-settings-c
build/lane3-settings-b
build/lane3-j6
build/lane3-sessionform
build/lane3-settings-a
build/lane3-members
build/lane3-thisweek
build/lane3-story
chore/87-align-python-3.12
v4.8.0-rc1
v4.7.1
v4.7.1-rc1
v4.7.0
v4.7.0-rc4
v4.7.0-rc3
v4.7.0-rc2
v4.7.0-rc1
v4.6.2
v4.6.2-rc4
v4.6.2-rc3
v4.6.2-rc2
v4.6.2-rc1
v4.6.1
v4.6.1-rc1
v4.6.0
v4.6.0-rc2
v4.6.0-rc1
v4.5.3
v4.5.3-rc1
v4.5.2
v4.5.2-rc1
v4.5.1
v4.5.1-rc2
v4.5.1-rc1
v4.5.0
v4.5.0-rc12
v4.5.0-rc11
v4.5.0-rc10
v4.5.0-rc9
v4.5.0-rc8
v4.5.0-rc7
v4.5.0-rc6
v4.5.0-rc5
v4.5.0-rc4
v4.5.0-rc3
v4.5.0-rc2
v4.5.0-rc1
v4.4.1
v4.4.0
v4.3.0
v4.2.3
v4.2.2
v4.2.1
v4.2.0
v4.1.2
v4.1.1
v4.1.0
v4.0.1
v4.0.0
v3.11.4
v3.11.3
v3.11.2
v3.11.1
v3.11.0
v3.10.0
v3.9.1
v3.9.0
v3.8.0
v3.7.0
v3.6.1
v3.6.0
v3.5.0
v3.4.1
v3.4.0
v3.3.0
v3.2.0
v3.1.0
v3.0.0
v2.1.0
v2.0.0
v1.1.0
v1.0.0
v0.12.0
v0.11.0
v0.10.0
v0.9.1
v0.3.3
v0.9.0
v0.8.0
v0.3.2
v0.3.1
v0.3.0
v0.7.0
v0.6.0
v0.5.0
v0.4.0
v0.2.1
v0.2.0
v0.1.1
v0.1.0
Labels
Clear labels
backend
Issue related to the backend
bot
Issue related to the bot
bug
Something is not working
duplicate
This issue or pull request already exists
enhancement
New feature
frontend
Issue related to the frontend
help wanted
Need some help
invalid
Something is wrong
question
More information is needed
recording
Issue related to the recording system
security
Security hardening / vulnerability work
wontfix
This won't be fixed
No labels
backend
bot
bug
duplicate
enhancement
frontend
help wanted
invalid
question
recording
security
wontfix
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set
Reference
rbrooks/Quest-Board#333
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Severity: CRITICAL. Found in the August 2026 session lifecycle review (#319). This is the issue that makes accuracy independent of model size.
Why
The two reported failure modes — scrambled chronology and misattributed actions — are both currently trusted to the model. This makes them checked.
Crucially, the check is pure code and free. It runs the same way on a 9B local model and on a frontier hosted one. Given that self-hosted is a first-class target, this is the only design whose correctness floor does not ride on model size.
Proposed fix
After the map phase, before any prose is generated:
evidencetimestamp must correspond to a real transcript line.narratedand the actor must appear in the text of a cited GM line.t_start <= t_end, both inside the session, and consistent with the cited evidence.sorted()guarantee rather than a model behaviour. This is the entire point.Beats that fail validation are flagged, not silently dropped — surface them to the GM as "unverified" so a real event with a bad citation is recoverable rather than invisible. Silent dropping would trade one invisible failure for another.
Acceptance criteria
sorted(), not by the modelVerified against acceptance criteria, and five defects fixed in
152048e. This is the issue whose stated purpose is that the accuracy floor "does not ride on model size" because the check is pure code — so a check that does not run matters more here than anywhere else in the pipeline.Criteria
validate_beatsis synchronous and makes no request.t_start <= t_endwas repaired in_coerce_beat, never recorded._coerce_beatclampedt_starttotranscript_seconds, thenvalidate_beatstestedbeat.t_start > transcript_seconds."starts after the session ends"could not be appended under any input.sorted()— and the sort key is now derived from verified data rather than a field nothing checked.used_beatswas computed every run and never persisted, so the runs that skipped validation were the ones leaving no trace. Now every run gets a row.The test that could not fail
test_a_beat_starting_after_the_session_ends_is_flaggedasserted onlyresult.beat.t_start <= max(index), which the clamp guarantees unconditionally. It never touchedresult.okorresult.problems. Its own comment hedged — "the range problem may resolve" — which reads like the author noticing and writing a weaker assertion rather than chasing it down.Why the evidence check re-anchors instead of rejecting
My first implementation flagged a beat whose range contained none of its citations. The
scrambled_chronologyeval fixture immediately showed that was wrong: all five of its beats failed, so five real, correctly-attributed events dropped out of the summary. That fixture exists precisely to demonstrate this gap — its notes say so, and its expectedchronology_tau: -1.0encoded the defect.The evidence has already been checked against the transcript; the declared range has been checked by nothing. When they disagree, the verified value wins. So the range is re-anchored onto the citations, which makes the chronology guarantee stronger than it was — the sort key now comes from transcript-verified timestamps rather than a model-supplied field.
That fixture now scores
tau = +1.0with coverage, attribution and validation all 1.0. Its expectations and notes are rewritten to record the fix rather than the gap; the five reversed timestamps still make it hand-checkable in both directions.A hallucinated citation is never used as an anchor — that would trade a wrong time the validator reported for a wrong time it invented.
BeatValidation.repairscarries corrections, separate fromproblemsand not affectingok: a beat the code could fix did not fail. Persisted tosession_beats.repairsand exposed through #424's API, because a silent correction is indistinguishable from a correct answer.dedupe_beats preferred hallucinations
It kept whichever duplicate had more citations, with no reference to the verdict — and
gather_validated_beatsvalidates before merging, so both sides already carried one. A second-pass beat citing the same real line plus one invented stamp beat a clean single-citation beat.render_beats_for_composeskips failing beats, so the event then vanished from the summary having been both correctly extracted and correctly checked. Verified beats now win outright.The loop's docstring described a filter that did not exist
"'Did this pass find anything new' has to mean anything new that survives checking" sat three lines above
gained = len(merged) - len(validations), which counted flagged beats. A pass of fresh hallucinations looked like progress and ran to the cap — a full re-extraction over every window, paid for nothing.test_a_pass_of_pure_hallucination_does_not_keep_the_loop_runningpassed for the wrong reason: its invented beat was identical every pass, sodedupe_beatscollapsed it. It would have gone on passing if the.okfilter it is named for were deleted — which it was, because it never existed. It now varies actor and stamp per pass, and fails against the old code.Verified by mutation, not by reading
Reverting
gainedand the dedupe rule fails exactly the three tests named above and nothing else._coerce_beat's silent discards are now counted and logged.1,306 → 1,324 passing. Migration
f7a8b0c1d2e3, applied and rolled back against a real database. Closing.